• Announcements

    • PULL Archiving   07/22/20

      Hi all, I paid the server bill for the month so the site can be archived, sorry for the mess, didn't realize there'd be such an uproar. The site's in read-only mode. Happy archiving. Here's a link to a user-made PULL discord server: https://discord.gg/vZFEm75

YandereDev/ Evaxephon General Thread


11762 posts in this topic

Posted

Yeah, the design is definitely cute and original (chubby!!) and it could work, but the artstyle doesn't.... gel together? If you are drawing that cartoony and small, you shouldn't shove too many details in the face. And with that much detail on the nostril, it looks like the nose is too upturned.

I know some of you compared it to SJW drawings and I don't disagree, but I also see the ugly "adult animation" style in it.

I really thought the slight chubbiness was intentional? That just makes things kind of sadder in a way. also yes, the nose is way too detailed and it just straight-up looks unappealing. I think the eyes are fine but I don’t really have much comments on it.

Not to be a party pooper, but Lovesick is just as much of an unfinished project as YanSim is at the moment. I see everyone getting hyped up and it just reminds me of the hype for past YanSim clones, you know, the ones who crashed? The past games also clogged up the thread... For no payoff in the end. I agree with washi_tape, let's move this discussion to another thread.

I’ve checked the Yandev sub forum and there’s another inactive thread that talks about “fixing what’s Yandere Simulator”, so I think that counts.
Fixing Yandere Simulator - PULL edition: https://prettyuglylittleliar.net/topic/3983-fixing-yandere-simulator-pull-edition/

1

Share this post


Link to post

Posted

I really thought the slight chubbiness was intentional? That just makes things kind of sadder in a way. also yes, the nose is way too detailed and it just straight-up looks unappealing. I think the eyes are fine but I don’t really have much comments on it.

I’ve checked the Yandev sub forum and there’s another inactive thread that talks about “fixing what’s Yandere Simulator”, so I think that counts.
Fixing Yandere Simulator - PULL edition: https://prettyuglylittleliar.net/topic/3983-fixing-yandere-simulator-pull-edition/

Thanks for bringing it to attention! I didn't catch that before! I made a comment on it so if y'all wanna continue the conversation you can pitch in your critiques and suggestions there.

1

Share this post


Link to post

Posted

If the artist is friends with the devs it just seems weird that they would choose them to do the art. I mean you would know if your friend's art was shit, right? I mean bad art can be suicide for a game.

It depends on the skills of the gamedevs. Touhou for example never had professional art but still got a huge fanbase during the time it was the most popular because the games were seriously unique and good. However, DrApeis isn't Zun and the game is just Yansim 2.0 with all of it's flaws, it's nothing revolutionary. I don't think the artist will cause the death of Loveletter, but it will hurt the popularity.

I don't know how the news went about because I'm not in the server, but there should have been a clear ref with notes about the body to prevent these kinds of issues from happening. For example, Asui Tsuyu from BNHA has an official ref sheet where the creator says that Asui purposely has large hands/legs/eyes so that when people draw her, there can be some consistency. Is everyone going to adhere to those notes? Of course not, but it's good practice to include that information anyway to clear up any questions about the character's design. It gets the message across far more productively than repeating "it's my style." My take is that the team should get an official artist who has the style, experience and professionalism to better represent the game's intentions moving forward.

Ignoring official constructions from a character sheet and changing the design 'because it's my style' just comes off unprofessional. It would be fine if the artist made her chubby for her own fanarts but making her chubby for the official artworks despite that not being intended just feels off. As said I don't have a problem with her being plus-size, in fact I think that makes her a bit cuter.

But it bugs me a lot that the artist said Bow-chan is not supposed to be plus-size yet draws her that way because of her style. If she had just said 'Yeah, she is gonna be chubby in the game' I would see no problem here but the fact that she pointed out that won't be the case ('she is not chubby, that's just my style!' and 'I decided to make her chubby') gives off even stronger SJW/tumblr artstyle vibes since this means we will have to expect her to change all other designs on a whim as well.

Not to be a party pooper, but Lovesick is just as much of an unfinished project as YanSim is at the moment. I see everyone getting hyped up and it just reminds me of the hype for past YanSim clones, you know, the ones who crashed? The past games also clogged up the thread... For no payoff in the end. I agree with washi_tape, let's move this discussion to another thread.

I created a Yansim clone thread, so this thread won't get derailed anymore

11

Share this post


Link to post

Posted

If the artist is friends with the devs it just seems weird that they would choose them to do the art. I mean you would know if your friend's art was shit, right? I mean bad art can be suicide for a game.

mama shortcake reacts like mulberry, i really hate to say it

4

Share this post


Link to post

Posted (edited)

Osana's official announcement is set for the 1st of august. Alex hinted it in his latest blog post and on his discord server. There will probably be a new build including her but it's unclear if that will be the demo. Probably not. I'd be surprised if all graphics had been replaced and there also aren't new 3d models yet. Alex seems to just release Osana to save his game since he's facing all the backlash now.

Keeping my fingers crossed for that august 1st build and if Osana is just thrown into it. It seems to be Alex' desperate try on fixing the current mess since he can't really do much aside from releasing Osana to have people keep interest in yansim.

My bet is that on august 1st we'll get a new blog post starting with: 'Today should have been the day Osana was supposed to be released.' He'll probably just drop Hate and shame 2 instead.

Edited by CosplayQueen
10

Share this post


Link to post

Posted

On today’s news on Alex being an asshole, he stole a random 10 year old’s drawing on the internet and recolored it. Dude is so incompetent that he can’t even make his own shitty drawings... How are you going to debunk this incident, Alex? 🤔

667CE852-978D-4471-9BD3-E5483C5B24D0.jpeg

10

Share this post


Link to post

Posted (edited)

On today’s news on Alex being an asshole, he stole a random 10 year old’s drawing on the internet and recolored it. Dude is so incompetent that he can’t even make his own shitty drawings... How are you going to debunk this incident, Alex? 🤔

Don't worry we'll hear his side of the story on his debunk page. LMFAO

"YandereDev stole a 10 year old's art and mocked/recolored it!"
"In short: No, I didn't."

Edited by fabienne
16

Share this post


Link to post

Posted

Osana's official announcement is set for the 1st of august. Alex hinted it in his latest blog post and on his discord server. There will probably be a new build including her but it's unclear if that will be the demo. Probably not. I'd be surprised if all graphics had been replaced and there also aren't new 3d models yet. Alex seems to just release Osana to save his game since he's facing all the backlash now.

Keeping my fingers crossed for that august 1st build and if Osana is just thrown into it. It seems to be Alex' desperate try on fixing the current mess since he can't really do much aside from releasing Osana to have people keep interest in yansim.

My bet is that on august 1st we'll get a new blog post starting with: 'Today should have been the day Osana was supposed to be released.' He'll probably just drop Hate and shame 2 instead.

Finally Yandy will have an important part of the game in his game bulid again after he removed the only rivial in the game,Oka.

I'm never going to get over Yandy getting rid of Oka-y because it wouldn't be that hard for Yandy to work on her and Osana at the same time. And it's not like there was even a reason to remove her. She stood in the club room basically and that's it.

On today’s news on Alex being an asshole, he stole a random 10 year old’s drawing on the internet and recolored it. Dude is so incompetent that he can’t even make his own shitty drawings... How are you going to debunk this incident, Alex? 🤔

667CE852-978D-4471-9BD3-E5483C5B24D0.jpeg

I'm going to need context on this. Also where the recolor Alex did is?

0

Share this post


Link to post

Posted (edited)

I'm going to need context on this. Also where the recolor Alex did is?

I had to scroll through reddit a bit, but I saw it was mentioned in one of his old videos. From what others sad, YanDev deleted it, but here's a reupload. He's complaining about the skills of volunteers and it shows up around 4:15.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tj-1Q8cqMks

Edited by garbledmess
lol i have no idea how to embed ignore me
1

Share this post


Link to post

Posted

I had to scroll through reddit a bit, but I saw it was mentioned in one of his old videos. From what others sad, YanDev deleted it, but here's a reupload. He's complaining about the skills of volunteers and it shows up around 4:15.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tj-1Q8cqMks

Yep,it's there.

fScnwGj.png

But how he found it is a mystery to me. I assume somehow with google,but what he googled to find it is the question.

5

Share this post


Link to post

Posted

I had to scroll through reddit a bit, but I saw it was mentioned in one of his old videos. From what others sad, YanDev deleted it, but here's a reupload. He's complaining about the skills of volunteers and it shows up around 4:15.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tj-1Q8cqMks

it literally blows my mind every single time seeing how self-entitled one person can be. he not only wants to have god tier HD++ professional quality work that takes hours to do, but he wants it for free. all for his shitty sandbox, with the most unoriginal characters ever, that is not even the actual game itself. :alpacabored:

6

Share this post


Link to post

Posted

it literally blows my mind every single time seeing how self-entitled one person can be. he not only wants to have god tier HD++ professional quality work that takes hours to do, but he wants it for free. all for his shitty sandbox, with the most unoriginal characters ever, that is not even the actual game itself. :alpacabored:

Dude should have been thankful at least that there were people still willing to help him in his sorry state.Quality is one thing but geez.

1

Share this post


Link to post

Posted

Each time you think Alex can't screw up more he never fails to deliver. Even when he is silent like at the moment he still manages to fuck up

3

Share this post


Link to post

Posted

wtf couldn't he just draw a stick figure on MS Paint instead of moking a 10 y-o's art ?

6

Share this post


Link to post

Posted

wtf couldn't he just draw a stick figure on MS Paint instead of moking a 10 y-o's art ?

That would require yandy doing something.

8

Share this post


Link to post