(I know I'm probably not going to change your opinion but) the way I see it, something did in fact happen. Both parties have said at some point that something happened (Melanie said "she never said no to what we did..." which implies/means they did something but she thinks it was consensual, and Timothy already made the accusations so both of them said something happened.) In my opinion, knowing that, it's just an argue of if it was consensual or not and I don't think "not saying no" is consent.
(Afaik, correct me if I'm wrong, it wasn't until Melanie's fans started saying "it didn't happen because they weren't together that day because _____" that Melanie changed her stance (Idk what she changed it to but from what I've heard, that's what happened?) Even though, again, previously, they BOTH admitted something happened? If that's the case that's a big "plot hole" so to speak imo.)
Well, in my personal opinion, I don't think that any of the pictures she has ever posted were completely natural: even back in her boho days. But I do think that the picture on the left is a lot closer to being natural than the one on the right (because back then she still looked fairly similar in candid pictures and pictures posted by other people.) It is possibly also edited, but not to the point where she was completely different in real life, and she did not erase all her natural features, so again to me it seems closer to natural even if not 100% natural.
I'm kind of glad they weren't called out by anyone super famous to be honest, while yes a lot of people would see their true colours: 1. I can GUARANTEE you that they would gain followers from it, because the way they look (or photoshop themselves to look) is what a lot of Koreaboos find pretty, and to some people appearance is all that matters, not behaviour. 2. I can also guarantee you that they would be happy that someone from BTS ACTUALLY (like in real life, not in another one of their made up stories) noticed/mentioned them no matter the context. 3. The negative attention they would surely get wouldn't stop them as we have seen, sure they disappear for a bit but it seems like to them all attention is good attention. It would probably just fuel their egos more. That's just my assumption though, I think the only way they'll stop is if they somehow mature. And I doubt they'll ever mature so long as at least 1 person believes their lies.
I think this is just that thing that happens at the start of a new month or end of an old month, people unpledge at that time (I think they do that to wait and see if they want to pay for the next month's reward or something like that?) I could be wrong though